Heat Pump vs Electric Resistance Calculator

Compare heat-pump and resistance heating costs with separate tariffs, climate assumptions and investment cash flows.

All heat demand, climate-band COPs, prices and costs are user-entered assumptions. Location supplies no weather, tariff or product data. This is not an equipment-sizing or HVAC design tool.

Useful heat reaching the rooms, not purchased fuel or electricity.
Share of delivered heat, not share of operating hours.
Useful heat / electricity at the same system boundary.
Include your expected defrost/distribution losses; no local weather lookup.
Backup is modelled at COP 1. The remaining heat uses the two compressor bands.
Only additional charges attributable to this scenario.
Constant nominal prices; no replacements or resale.
End-of-year running-cost savings.
Use zero when keeping existing equipment.
Useful heat at the rooms / purchased electricity. Distribution losses may reduce it.
May differ from the heat-pump tariff, for example off-peak storage heating.

About this tool

Compare a heat pump with electric resistance or storage heating using equal useful heat. Give each system its own electricity tariff and maintenance costs, then inspect how climate-band performance, backup heat and installation prices affect annual costs and payback.

How the calculation works

Heat-pump electricity is the sum of useful heat in each compressor band divided by its COP, plus electric resistance backup heat at COP 1. Existing heating electricity = useful heat / entered delivered-heat efficiency. Each energy amount uses its own tariff. Running cost adds maintenance and fixed charges. Installation premium = heat-pump cost - resistance option cost. Simple payback = positive premium / positive first-year saving. Discounted NPV = negative premium + the sum of each year-end saving / (1 + discount rate)^year.

Worked example

For 12,000 kWh useful heat, half at COP 4 and half at COP 2 without backup, a heat pump uses 4,500 kWh. At 0.25/kWh plus 200 annual maintenance it costs 1,325/year. Resistance heating at 100% delivered efficiency uses 12,000 kWh; at 0.25/kWh plus 50 maintenance it costs 3,050/year. Annual saving is 1,725. A 7,000 installation premium has about 4.06-year simple payback; the first positive year-end cumulative balance is year 5.

Compare tariffs as well as energy efficiency

A heat pump can use less electricity yet cost more under a sufficiently different tariff. Enter the prices actually applicable to each heating arrangement, including a realistic blended rate if the price varies by time of use. This calculator does not optimise charging or heating schedules.

Fixed charges should reflect costs attributable to each option. A household electricity connection charge that remains identical can be entered on both sides or omitted from both. Do not count the same unavoidable bill component as a saving.

Interpret payback and COP sensitivity separately

Simple payback repeats first-year savings without discounting. The year-end crossover and NPV use the selected horizon, while NPV also uses your nominal discount rate. A simple payback beyond that horizon is not a positive lifetime result.

Sensitivity rows scale both entered compressor COPs by 80%, 100% or 120%, bounded to the supported 0.01–10 range. Demand, heat shares, resistance backup, tariffs and other costs stay unchanged. These are comparison scenarios, not confidence intervals or manufacturer performance claims.

Assumptions and limitations

Prices and yearly heat demand remain constant. The resistance-efficiency input connects purchased electricity to useful heat at the rooms; it is not a heat-pump COP. An off-peak tariff for storage heating can differ from the heat-pump tariff. Backup heat is modelled at COP 1. Currency formatting does not convert rates.

The comparison is not a purchase recommendation or an equipment-sizing result. Heating schedules, storage losses, weather, delivery temperature and control strategy can alter actual costs. No cooling value, financing, incentives, replacements, resale or future electricity-price change is included.

Sources and editorial responsibility

Maintained by Renvoro Pty Ltd. Sources inform the methods and assumptions shown here; outputs have the limitations described on this page.

Guide updated 2026-11-04. Calculation method and source dates remain separate.

Method reviewed 2026-10-21. Calculation standards · Report an issue