Heat Pump vs Gas Heating Calculator

Compare equal delivered heat using climate-band COPs, backup, gas efficiency, standing charges and installation costs.

All heat demand, climate-band COPs, prices and costs are user-entered assumptions. Location supplies no weather, tariff or product data. This is not an equipment-sizing or HVAC design tool.

Useful heat reaching the rooms, not purchased fuel or electricity.
Share of delivered heat, not share of operating hours.
Useful heat / electricity at the same system boundary.
Include your expected defrost/distribution losses; no local weather lookup.
Backup is modelled at COP 1. The remaining heat uses the two compressor bands.
Only additional charges attributable to this scenario.
Constant nominal prices; no replacements or resale.
End-of-year running-cost savings.
Use zero when comparing against keeping existing equipment.
Use a seasonal value consistent with your gas bill energy basis.
Use the conversion stated on your bill; this example is not a regional standard.

About this tool

Compare a heat pump and gas heating for the same amount of useful heat delivered to your rooms. Separate compressor performance in two climate bands, electric backup, gas efficiency, standing charges and installation cost. A result can favour either option; no tariff, climate or equipment rating is inferred from your location.

How the calculation works

Compressor heat = annual useful heat x (1 - backup fraction). Compressor electricity = compressor heat x [milder heat share / milder COP + colder heat share / colder COP]. Resistance backup electricity equals backup heat at COP 1. Gas input energy = useful heat / seasonal delivered-heat efficiency. Gas units = input kWh / kWh per billed unit. Annual comparison saving = gas usage + gas maintenance + gas standing charge - heat-pump electricity - heat-pump maintenance - extra fixed costs - any retained gas standing charge. Incremental NPV subtracts the installation-price difference at year zero, then discounts each year-end saving.

Worked example

For 12,000 kWh useful heat, half the compressor heat at COP 4 and half at COP 2, with no resistance backup, electricity use is 1,500 + 3,000 = 4,500 kWh. At 0.25/kWh, 200 maintenance and 250 retained gas standing charge, heat-pump running cost is 1,575. Gas at 90% delivered efficiency needs 13,333.33 kWh; at 0.10/kWh plus 150 maintenance and 250 standing charge, it costs 1,733.33. Annual saving is 158.33. A 10,000 heat-pump installation versus 3,000 gas replacement has a 7,000 premium and about 44.21-year simple payback, beyond a 15-year projection.

Standing charges can change the conclusion

A gas standing charge is avoided only if the relevant gas service cost really disappears. If you retain gas for cooking, water heating or another appliance, leave the retained-charge option selected. Removing a charge in the calculator does not establish that your utility permits it to be removed.

Enter zero gas installation cost when the alternative is to keep existing equipment. Enter a replacement cost only when that replacement is part of the actual comparison. This separates a like-for-like future choice from assuming all existing spending is recoverable.

Use a seasonal energy balance rather than averaging COPs

For equal quantities of useful heat at COP 4 and COP 2, the combined compressor COP is about 2.67, not 3. Electricity is summed for each heat share before overall efficiency is calculated. Resistance backup adds electricity at COP 1 and can materially lower the system result.

The energy-only break-even COP compares variable gas and electricity prices at the entered gas efficiency. It deliberately excludes installation, maintenance and standing charges. Use the complete annual and discounted cash-flow tables for the broader entered-cost comparison.

Assumptions and limitations

COP inputs use the same useful-heat boundary as your demand estimate. Heat shares describe useful heat, not operating hours. Backup is electric resistance, not a dual-fuel gas backup. Tariffs, demand, maintenance and efficiency stay constant through the comparison. Gas billing conversions must match your bill energy basis; therm and MMBtu presets use International Table Btu.

This is not a heat-loss survey, equipment-sizing method, installation quote or recommendation to disconnect gas. Weather, humidity, defrost, distribution, capacity limits and control settings can change performance. The two-band model is a transparent scenario rather than an hourly weather simulation. Cooling, hot water, financing, incentives, replacements and resale are excluded.

Sources and editorial responsibility

Maintained by Renvoro Pty Ltd. Sources inform the methods and assumptions shown here; outputs have the limitations described on this page.

Guide updated 2026-11-04. Calculation method and source dates remain separate.

Method reviewed 2026-10-21. Calculation standards · Report an issue